Listen to a podcast discussion about this article.
One day, some bright-eyed grandchild is going to climb into Grandpa’s lap and ask a question no Baby Boomer is ever fully prepared to answer.
“Grandpa, what did you do in the Sexual Revolution?”
And Grandpa, suddenly fascinated by a spot on the living-room carpet, will likely clear his throat, stare into the middle distance, and say something like: “Well, son, mostly we spent thirty years proving your great-grandparents weren’t nearly as foolish as we thought.”
The Sexual Revolution was one of those moments when millions of otherwise intelligent people decided that several thousand years of accumulated human experience could be set aside because we’d finally figured everything out. Every generation gets a turn at this game. Some decide they’ll abolish war. Others decide they’ll abolish poverty. Ours decided we’d abolish consequences. Looking back, it was an ambitious project. We were young, healthy, optimistic, and convinced human nature was little more than a software problem awaiting an update.
It didn’t begin in a smoke-filled room of libertines plotting the downfall of Western civilization. It began because the children of postwar America grew up so comfortably that they finally had time to question everything. Our parents had survived the Depression and World War II. They built houses, started families, joined churches, and worried about practical matters like putting food on the table. We inherited the prosperity they created and promptly explained why they’d been doing life all wrong. That’s one of youth’s most reliable habits. Every generation believes it’s the first to discover freedom and the first to notice that old people can be irritating.
Then, in 1960, science delivered what seemed like a miracle. The birth control pill arrived and changed the arithmetic of sex in a way that would’ve astonished every previous generation. For the first time, millions believed sex could be separated from reproduction with a reliability that would’ve seemed magical only years earlier. It was a genuine breakthrough. But breakthroughs often arrive with unexpected side effects. Nobody buys a new invention for the fine print.
The culture was already primed for ignition. Alfred Kinsey revealed that Americans were engaging in all sorts of activities they publicly denied knowing about. Masters and Johnson turned the bedroom into something resembling a laboratory. Helen Gurley Brown assured young women that careers, independence, and romance weren’t mutually exclusive. Hugh Hefner persuaded a generation of young men that sophistication consisted largely of silk pajamas, bachelor pads, and an allergy to commitment. Add affluence, coeducational campuses, rock music, growing distrust of authority, and a youthful conviction that every tradition was an obstacle waiting to be knocked down, and the country began moving in a direction few would’ve predicted twenty years earlier. By the time Woodstock arrived, free love was less a philosophy than a civic improvement project.
Of course, national revolutions always sound grander in history books than they do while they’re happening. Out here in Beaver County, the Sexual Revolution didn’t arrive riding into town on a psychedelic bus. It arrived at Jerry’s Curb Service, where boys in GTOs, Road Runners, and Chevelles spent summer evenings circling the lot while girls leaned against hoods and pretended not to notice who was looking at whom. It arrived at the Spotlight 88 Drive-In, where a movie ticket conveniently provided three hours of darkness and privacy that no respectable living room could offer. The headlines were about Haight-Ashbury and Woodstock. The local version involved muscle cars, parking lots, and a generation discovering that freedom was every bit as complicated in Beaver County as it was in San Francisco.
What followed was remarkable not for its novelty but for its speed. Ideas that would’ve scandalized respectable society in the 1950s became ordinary conversation by the 1970s. Pornography emerged from the shadows and entered polite society. The film Deep Throat became a national sensation, which remains one of those historical facts that sounds invented whenever it’s repeated. Newspapers covered it. Television discussed it. Respectable people talked about it over cocktails while assuring one another they found the whole thing terribly shocking. The country spent years pretending not to be fascinated by something it couldn’t stop discussing.
Then came the era’s more ambitious social experiments. For a brief but memorable period, many educated Americans convinced themselves that jealousy was merely an outdated emotional response that could be overcome through communication, self-awareness, and perhaps enough California wine. Books like Open Marriage promised that mature adults could enjoy lifelong commitment while still shopping around for alternatives. Swinging clubs appeared. Stories circulated about key parties. Communes experimented with every imaginable variation of communal romance. Human beings have been trying to outsmart human nature since the beginning of recorded history, but rarely have so many pursued the project with such enthusiasm and confidence in their originality.
Unfortunately, human nature remained stubbornly unimpressed.
The bill arrived on schedule. Divorce rates climbed dramatically, reaching heights that would’ve shocked our grandparents. Families fractured. Children found themselves shuttling between households. Out-of-wedlock births increased. Sexually transmitted diseases spread. Then AIDS arrived in the 1980s, delivering the sort of devastating reminder reality occasionally provides when society becomes too convinced it has rewritten the rules. The hangover didn’t arrive all at once. Cultural hangovers never do. They appear gradually, one broken relationship, one lonely apartment, one disappointed child, and one difficult conversation at a time.
Even in Beaver County, reality eventually caught up. The fellow who’d once cruised Third Street in a Judge GTO with Led Zeppelin rattling the windows eventually found himself writing alimony checks. The couples who’d met beneath the glowing screen of the Spotlight 88 eventually found themselves sitting through divorce hearings, attending their children’s graduations together, or exchanging strained pleasantries in the checkout line at Giant Eagle. History records revolutions in slogans. Life records them in mortgage payments, custody arrangements, and awkward encounters in the frozen-food aisle.
To be fair, the revolution wasn’t all folly. Women gained genuine freedom and opportunity. Conversations about sexuality became more honest. Some hypocrisies deserved exposure. Some taboos deserved retirement. Nobody should pretend the world of 1955 was perfect. It wasn’t. But revolutions have a habit of overshooting their targets. What began as a sensible demand for greater freedom often drifted into the belief that freedom itself was the highest good. We discovered, as generations before us had, that freedom is wonderful right up until it becomes the only thing.
And that’s where the story takes its most unexpected turn. The Sexual Revolution promised to free us from old rules. Instead, it created an entire industry devoted to managing the consequences of living without them. Therapists, relationship coaches, dating apps, self-help authors, family courts, fertility clinics, and endless podcasts now labor around the clock explaining how to achieve the stability, intimacy, trust, and commitment that previous generations mostly acquired by following the customs we spent decades dismantling. We declared independence from tradition and then hired consultants to help us recreate its benefits.
So what did we do in the Sexual Revolution, kids? We launched one of the largest social experiments in modern history to escape the constraints of our grandparents, only to spend the next half-century rediscovering why those constraints existed. The irony isn’t that the revolution failed; much of it succeeded beyond anyone’s expectations. The irony is that its greatest legacy may be convincing millions of people that the old wisdom had to be tested, broken, and painfully reassembled before it could be believed. After all the manifestos, protests, books, therapies, and cultural upheaval, we ended up paying premium prices to relearn lessons that had once been handed down free of charge.
Grandpa’s generation called that progress.
His grandparents would’ve called it growing up.
